Destava

AVP of Underwriting- Fidelity and Crime

GAIC Great American Insurance Company is hiring for AVP of Underwriting- Fidelity and Crime in New York, NY (USA). Hybrid, Executive level, $210k–$255k a year stated. First seen November 13, 2026; open as of November 19, 2026. Jobs taken straight from company career pages — no aggregator in between.

Save to applyFree forever. No commitment, no card required.

Company
GAIC Great American Insurance Company
Where
New York, NY (USA)
Arrangement
Hybrid
Level
Executive
Pay stated
$210k–$255k a year
First seen
November 13, 2026
Listed via
Workday
Open for
6 days, as of November 19, 2026
Visa sponsorship
Not offered

Applying to this one?

See how well you fit, before you apply

Save it to your board. Add your résumé once, and Destava shows where you are strong, what is missing and how to pitch yourself, then tailors your résumé to this posting.

  1. Found it
  2. Save it
  3. See your fit

Free forever. No commitment, no card required.

Or apply on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site

About this job

This role leads the Fidelity and Crime underwriting team in New York, focusing on financial institutions and commercial crime. It involves strategy, operations, and team development in a hybrid work setting. The position requires US work authorization and offers a salary range of $210,000 to $255,000.

Schedule: Hybrid role combining in-office and remote work, with a meaningful on-site presence expected.

Responsibilities

  • Lead and develop an experienced underwriting team, promoting accountability and engagement.
  • Drive underwriting strategy for the Fidelity and Crime profit center, ensuring disciplined risk selection.
  • Oversee daily underwriting operations, including workflow, file quality, and service standards.
  • Underwrite or guide complex Fidelity and Crime accounts.
  • Achieve premium and profit growth targets using market insights and broker engagement.
  • Strengthen broker and client relationships to identify opportunities.
  • Use personal market connections to generate new business and partnerships.
  • Collaborate with divisional colleagues to support cross-selling and coordinated strategies.
  • Monitor portfolio performance, including rate adequacy, retention, and loss trends.
  • Lead planning, forecasting, and reporting for the territory.
  • Develop and execute the annual plan with financial discipline.
  • Manage operational expenses within budget.
  • Ensure consistent underwriting guidelines, pricing, documentation, and compliance.
  • Coach and mentor team members through referrals and training.
  • Represent the division at industry and broker events, with local travel.
  • Collaborate with claims and internal partners to support decisions and customer experience.

Requirements

  • 15-20+ years of underwriting experience in Fidelity or Crime, or substantial experience in Financial Institutions or related specialty lines.
  • 7+ years of people leadership experience with a record of building and managing high-performing teams.
  • Strong technical underwriting skills for complex accounts and larger risks.
  • Proven portfolio management including profitability, growth planning, and analytics.
  • Established broker relationships and ability to grow business through connections.
  • Strong strategic, communication, and stakeholder management skills.
  • Ability to work hybrid in NYC and travel locally or occasionally for divisional needs.
  • Must be authorized to work in the US without visa sponsorship.

Benefits

  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage for full-time employees.
  • Wellness plans, parental leave, adoption assistance, and tuition reimbursement.
  • Paid time off and paid holidays for full-time and eligible part-time employees.
  • 401(k) plan with company match.
  • Employee stock purchase plan.
  • Commuter benefits.

Read more and apply on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's site

Questions about this job

When was this AVP of Underwriting- Fidelity and Crime job at GAIC Great American Insurance Company posted?

November 13, 2026

Destava first saw it on November 13, 2026, on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page (Workday).

Is GAIC Great American Insurance Company still accepting applications for it?

Open as of November 19, 2026

It was open on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site when Destava last read it, on November 19, 2026, 6 days after we first saw it. When the company takes it down, this page says the job has closed.

How do I apply for AVP of Underwriting- Fidelity and Crime at GAIC Great American Insurance Company?

On GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site

On GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site, at gaig.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com: open the posting. Destava does not take the application. Save the job to your Destava board to track it, see how well you fit and tailor your résumé to it.

Is this GAIC Great American Insurance Company job posting legit?

Listed on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page

Destava read it on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page at gaig.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com, run on Workday, not on a job board. First seen November 13, 2026. Apply on the company's own site, and never pay to apply for a job.

What does this job pay?

$210k–$255k a year

The posting states $210k–$255k a year.

Is this job remote?

Hybrid

It is hybrid: part of the week on site in New York, NY (USA), the rest from home.

Does GAIC Great American Insurance Company sponsor a visa for this job?

Not offered

No. The posting says you must already be authorized to work there.

How many insurance underwriters jobs are open in New York?

131 open

131 open, 54 of them new this week, at 61 companies: see them all.

With Destava: Save to apply · Tailor my résumé · Write a cover letter

This page includes information from the O*NET 31.0 Database by the U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration (USDOL/ETA). Used under the CC BY 4.0 license. O*NET® is a trademark of USDOL/ETA.