Destava

Casualty Claims Supervisor - AgriBusiness

GAIC Great American Insurance Company is hiring for Casualty Claims Supervisor - AgriBusiness in Cincinnati, OH (USA). Hybrid, Manager level. First seen November 13, 2026; open as of November 19, 2026. Jobs taken straight from company career pages — no aggregator in between.

Save to applyFree forever. No commitment, no card required.

Company
GAIC Great American Insurance Company
Where
Cincinnati, OH (USA)
Arrangement
Hybrid
Level
Manager
First seen
November 13, 2026
Listed via
Workday
Open for
6 days, as of November 19, 2026
Visa sponsorship
Not offered

Applying to this one?

See how well you fit, before you apply

Save it to your board. Add your résumé once, and Destava shows where you are strong, what is missing and how to pitch yourself, then tailors your résumé to this posting.

  1. Found it
  2. Save it
  3. See your fit

Free forever. No commitment, no card required.

Or apply on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site

About this job

This role supervises a claims team in the AgriBusiness division, based in Cincinnati, OH. It involves managing daily operations, litigation, and claim investigations, plus coaching staff. After training, the position requires working on-site four days a week, with one remote day.

Schedule: after training, on-site four days a week, one remote day; core in-office days Tuesday–Thursday, fourth day determined by business needs

Responsibilities

  • coordinate daily team operations and workflow
  • manage litigation handling
  • supervise liability claim investigations to confirm coverage and determine liability, compensability, and damages
  • review and approve claim settlements and reserves within set authority
  • advise team on claim files and extend settlement authority after review
  • set reserves and provide reports or recommendations to Corporate Claims or senior management as needed
  • oversee team priorities and coordinate daily tasks
  • occasionally perform tasks alongside direct reports
  • operate under policies and procedures with limited oversight
  • coach and manage staff performance, and participate in talent selection, development, and performance management decisions
  • perform other duties as assigned

Requirements

  • coordinate daily team operations and workflow
  • manage litigation handling
  • supervise liability claim investigations to confirm coverage and determine liability, compensability, and damages
  • review and approve claim settlements and reserves within set authority
  • advise team on claim files and extend settlement authority after review
  • set reserves and provide reports or recommendations to Corporate Claims or senior management as needed
  • oversee team priorities and coordinate daily tasks
  • occasionally perform tasks alongside direct reports
  • operate under policies and procedures with limited oversight
  • coach and manage staff performance, and participate in talent selection, development, and performance management decisions
  • perform other duties as assigned
  • bachelor’s degree in business administration, risk management and insurance, finance, or related field, or equivalent experience
  • minimum 5 years of property and casualty claims handling experience
  • typically manage 2 or more reports
  • provide training to new team members
  • exhibit exceptional analytical, negotiation, and problem-solving abilities
  • ensure team knowledge of insurance policies, coverage, and claims procedures, and stay updated on industry laws and regulations
  • authorized to work in the U.S. without current or future visa sponsorship
  • after training, work on-site four days a week, with one remote day; core in-office days are Tuesday–Thursday, fourth day determined by business needs

Nice to have

  • professional designation (e.g., Associate in Claims) completed or in progress
  • coverage and farm claims experience

Benefits

  • medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • wellness plans
  • parental leave
  • adoption assistance
  • tuition reimbursement
  • Paid Time Off and paid holidays
  • 401(k) plan with company match
  • employee stock purchase plan
  • commuter benefits

Read more and apply on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's site

Questions about this job

When was this Casualty Claims Supervisor - AgriBusiness job at GAIC Great American Insurance Company posted?

November 13, 2026

Destava first saw it on November 13, 2026, on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page (Workday).

Is GAIC Great American Insurance Company still accepting applications for it?

Open as of November 19, 2026

It was open on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site when Destava last read it, on November 19, 2026, 6 days after we first saw it. When the company takes it down, this page says the job has closed.

How do I apply for Casualty Claims Supervisor - AgriBusiness at GAIC Great American Insurance Company?

On GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site

On GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own site, at gaig.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com: open the posting. Destava does not take the application. Save the job to your Destava board to track it, see how well you fit and tailor your résumé to it.

Is this GAIC Great American Insurance Company job posting legit?

Listed on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page

Destava read it on GAIC Great American Insurance Company's own careers page at gaig.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com, run on Workday, not on a job board. First seen November 13, 2026. Apply on the company's own site, and never pay to apply for a job.

Is this job remote?

Hybrid

It is hybrid: part of the week on site in Cincinnati, OH (USA), the rest from home.

Does GAIC Great American Insurance Company sponsor a visa for this job?

Not offered

No. The posting says you must already be authorized to work there.

How many claims adjusters, examiners, and investigators jobs are open in Cincinnati?

15 open

15 open, 4 of them new this week, at 8 companies: see them all.

With Destava: Save to apply · Tailor my résumé · Write a cover letter

This page includes information from the O*NET 31.0 Database by the U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration (USDOL/ETA). Used under the CC BY 4.0 license. O*NET® is a trademark of USDOL/ETA.